“No Reply” by The Beatles.
Here’s what’s weird about The Beatles, or maybe special —- biking home tonight this song came on my iPhone (yes I listen to music while I bike, but only once I start crossing the Williamsburg Bridge because from there until my home in Greenpoint there’s no traffic, really) and it struck me as the perfect song that could be. It’s a minor Beatles song but tonight it was the best song I could imagine — for these three minutes it was my favorite song!
Maybe because it’s cool windy night, and Brooklyn looked pretty as I biked through it? Maybe the song fit that environment. It’s a sparse song with a fair amount of reverberation, as if it were recorded in a basement. Still very crisp. Somehow old Beatles albums sound both crisp and full of echo. I guess George Martin knew what he was doing, or was this Geoff Emerick who would handle that? Anyway, it sounds very cool.
John is so angry on this song — mad at this girl for sleeping with someone else. (I love “walking hand in hand in my place” as a euphemism for “fucking someone else” or at least I assume that’s what it means. Hand-holding = sex in pre Sgt. Pepper’s Beatles songs). What strikes me as strange about THAT is … when was John Lennon rejected by a girl? The Beatles were probably getting laid during most of their waking hours starting from when they were in Hamburg. By the time John wrote this song, he was a rich and internationally famous 23 year old — married and also thick with groupies at all times. He was wanting for nothing. Did he have an affair with a girl one night who snubbed him the next, and he parlayed that feeling into this song? Did someone make him wait 10 extra minutes for a blow job and he got so mad he wrote No Reply? Or was he still so crushed by his mother’s death 4 years earlier that could just tap into that whenever he wanted to sound like Buddy Holly but better, way better?
Paul’s harmonies are nice and angry. Someone real angry — like Afghan Whigs angry, like UNFAIRLY angry — should cover this song. Not big and loud — but SEETHING and QUIET and SO SO SO MAD.
The Beatles made a simple deal when they all sold their souls to the Devil: pack into our songs every feeling that everyone will ever have.



Elmo